Class
By R. Emmett Tyrrell Jr.
There is an awful lot of blowzy thought swirling around the proposed mosque to be raised two blocks from Ground Zero in lower Manhattan. Frankly I doubt that at any other time in our history such a debate would be taking place. People would know that when thugs intoning Allahu Akbar have slaughtered hundreds of innocent Americans on American soil it is inappropriate to raise a mosque nearby.
The majority of Americans alive today know this.
Polling indicates that with them it is a nonstarter.
Now the Anti-Defamation Leagues national director Abraham H. Foxman has weighed in on the side of good sense. One hopes this debate is coming to an end.
In the current issue of The American Spectator Angelo M. Codevilla posits two Americas. The first is the Ruling Class:
Todays ruling class he writes from Boston to San Diego was formed by an educational system that exposed them to the same ideas and gave them remarkably uniform guidance as well as tastes and habits.… Many began their careers in government and leveraged their way into the private sector.… Hence whether formally in the government out of it or halfway Americas ruling class speaks the language and has the tastes habits and tools of bureaucrats. It rules uneasily over the majority of Americans not orientated to the government.
The majority of Americans comprise the Country Class. The Country Class or the Country Party has come down against the mosque and it goes far beyond New Yorkers. It embraces Americans from all over. They oppose the mosque and their opposition is growing. On the other side the Ruling Classs spokesman is not surprisingly Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg of New York though he could be
from Chicago or Boston or Washington D.C. Apropos of the mosque he says:
What is great about America and particularly New York is we welcome everybody and if we are so afraid of something like this what does it say about us?
First of all we do not welcome everybody not drugs lords not Nazis not Islamofascists. Secondly we are not so afraid of something like this. Rather we recognize it as an affront to the fallen and to the Nation. Ad arguendo the affront might not be intended by those wishing to put up the mosque but it will be recognized by others throughout the world as an affront. Possibly it will be recognized as a sign of the triumph of Islam over non-believers. It ought not to go up. The latest to join with the Country Class is Abe Foxman. He has done so at great cost to himself. He has members of the Ruling Party all around him. Yet even he has been guilty of blowzy thought. He says that Survivors of the Holocaust are entitled to feelings that are irrational. Likewise the families that lost loved ones in September 11 are entitled to feelings that are irrational he claims. Their anguish entitles them says Foxman to positions that others would categorize as irrational or bigoted. Thus because they object Foxman would build the mosque a mile away. There is nothing irrational or bigoted about thinking that a mosque does not belong at Ground Zero or at the Pentagon or on the Pennsylvania countryside where United Flight 93 crashed. Americans traditionally raise on such sites monuments to freedom to courage to the sacrifices of those lost. Now the Ruling Class wants to place a mosque at the site of September 11. It is the only time I can recall the Ruling Class ever being in favor of placing a religious manifestation anywhere. Yet in favoring this mosque the Ruling Class does put itself squarely in opposition to the Country Class so it does have a logic to it. Will the Ruling Class have its way? I have my doubts. The Country Class is getting stronger. It is not opposed to the building of mosques just not on the sites of where so many brave Americans were killed by people who hated them because they were American.
The Country Class will decide the monuments for the brave.
The Ruling Class can eat cake.
R. Emmett Tyrrell Jr. is founder and editor in chief of The American Spectator. His new book After the Hangover: The Conservatives Road to Recovery was published on April 20 by Thomas Nelson.
