Following widespread concern about President Obamas nationally televised address to schoolchildren many parents and schools are opting to forgo the Sept. 8 speech.
School officials have been asked to take a break from normal educational activities to allow students to view the speech from the president and participate in recommended brainstorming exercises following the broadcast. Obama will give the speech at Wakefield High School in Arlington Va. The speech is scheduled to broadcast live at 12 noon EST on C-SPAN and at whitehouse.gov.
But parents across the nation are complaining about the speech taking up valuable classroom instruction time and possibly indoctrinating young children.
According to a letter from U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan The president will challenge students to work hard set educational goals and take responsibility for their learning. …
He will also call for a shared responsibility and commitment on the part of students parents and educators to ensure that every child in every school receives the best education possible so they can compete in the global economy for good jobs and live rewarding and productive lives as American citizens.
Some schools allow parents to opt-out
Donald Phillips superintendent of Californias Poway Unified School District sent a letter to parents Wednesday announcing that the district will not be encouraging teachers to include the viewing of the presidents speech as a part of a supplemental classroom learning activity. If teachers choose to do so they must inform parents by Friday and give them an opportunity to opt-out of the Tuesday broadcast.
Who Killed the Constitution? Heres a dirty little secret: The bedrock of our country is ... dead
Students who opt-out will be assigned alternate learning activities outside of the classroom during the speech and any follow-up discussions.
Additionally the district is providing a link to a copy of the presidents speech so parents may decide whether they want to view it at home with their children.
We believe the presidents address would be the most beneficial if you choose to view it together at home as a family the memo states. We believe any discussion with your child or children around the importance of education and goal-setting could be both meaningful and appropriate.
Officials with Texas Keller Independent School District said they will allow students to view the presidential address. However a district notice states If parents do not want their student(s) to watch the broadcast parents may dismiss their student(s) during that time and not be penalized. Additionally the children will not be required to use the United States Education Department materials for suggested brainstorming assignments after the speech. Many Texas school districts are asking parents to contact principals if they do not wish for their children to view the speech while several schools have opted not to show the broadcast.
Stephanie Klick Tarrant County Republican Party chairwoman told the Fort Worth Star-Telegram that many Texas families are speaking out against plans to air the broadcast in schools.
Were hearing from parents and grandparents that are not very happy. They really feel like it is political indoctrination Klick said. People dont like this. I have heard from some families that are planning to keep their kids home.
The Houston Independent School District has directed principals to give parents advance notice if they are planning lessons around Obamas speech. Parents may opt-out their children. According to a Houston Chronicle report Children pulled out of school for the day will cost districts about $35 per child as state funding for schools is based on daily attendance.
In Utah school districts are taking precautions ahead of the speech according to KSL 5 News. Salt Lake City School District is advising schools to have teachers notify parents if they plan on airing the address in class and then allowing an opt-out. Some principals will be sending home notices if their schools plan to show the speech.
One Utah father told the Deseret News he will pull his four children out of school rather than allow them to watch the Obama broadcast.
We will go on a picnic and read the Constitution learn something useful he said.
Wisconsin school districts have been hearing from concerned parents according to the Associated Press. Palm Beach County Fla. public schools may not run the broadcast. In Columbia Mo. a district spokeswoman said kids wont be seeing the speech at all.
Meanwhile Atlas Shrugs Pamela Gellar blasted the White House and the Department of Education for spelling errors in its Indoctrination Day announcement noting that she will keep her children home from school on Sept. 8.
Geller took this screenshot of the announcement:
Yes your education tax dollars at work Geller wrote. Math geography spelling English thats for fascists! Whats important is junk science global hoaxes and the green-colored slave labor market. Live for the sake of the man and like it.
She continued Obama stay away from my children. ... My kids will not be in school on the 8th (and neither should yours).
Objections to presidents speech
Several bloggers discussed their thoughts on the presidents address to schoolchildren on the Free Republic website. The following are some comments about the upcoming speech:
- Im so mad right now I think my head will explode.
- You dont mess with peoples kids! Theres a line and hed better no cross it or he will cause a revolution in this country.
- This idea reeks of Bill Ayers.
- He is treading on very dangerous ground.
- Thank God we live in Alaska. Thats 8 a.m. up here and most of the students are still eating breakfast. Ill read the transcript later in case I want to experience nausea.
- Why does this have to be a live broadcast? Why must all schools halt at the appointed time to listen to our dear leader? It doesnt accommodate children or the families very well.
- Isnt it time for parents to organize a national campaign to pull their kids out of school on that day?
- Have you called your local school today to express your opinion about the Obama propaganda video and lesson plan? If not now is a good time. Even if you do not have children in school you pay taxes to support it and you have to live with the results of its teachings so you have a stake in the outcome.
- I would keep my kid out for the whole day instead of just a couple of hours the school districts receive an amount per student based on their daily attendance so the thing to do is to hit them in the pocketbook where it hurts.
- I will be keeping both of my children out the entire day. Our school district has said they will be airing the speech and also have other activities planned around it. Knowing what some of these school boards and administrators are like those activities could be more damaging than an Obama speech.
- I assume brownshirts will be taking the names of those who opt out.
The Nationwide Tea Party Coalition announced its Hall Pass on That website with several suggested actions for parents who do not approve of their children participating in the presentation. The coalition offers the following suggestions:
- Contact the childs school to find out whether it is participating in the program.
- If your childs school is participating ask what alternatives there are for the children of families who wish for their students to learn about the establishment of the country respective to the Founding Fathers intentions. Discussions may focus on the Constitution the definition and actions of a republic and the responsibility of elected leaders to their constituents.
- Ask if the school can excuse your child from the presentation and instead receive a DVD of the address and copy of the activity directives to be evaluated by parents at a later date.
- Request a meeting with the school board superintendent and principal to inquire as to why parents were excluded from the decision-making process of this event.
- What is the president trying to tell me to do?
- What is the president asking me to do?
- What new ideas and actions is the president challenging me to think about?
- Why does President Obama want to speak with us today?
- How will he inspire us?
- How will he challenge us?
- What might he say?
Among the activities suggested for pre-K to 6th grade students were to write letters to themselves about what they can do to help the president and discuss what the president wants us to do.
According to the report the suggestion about writing letters has been changed to: Write letters to themselves about how they can achieve their short-term and long-term education goals. These would be collected and redistributed at an appropriate later date by the teacher to make students accountable to their goals.
Lessons prompt concerns about illegal activity
The Texas Justice Foundation warned the proposed classroom activities for teachers as to how they should handle the presidents Sept. 8th speech to American schoolchildren reveal that illegal activity may occur if the recommendations are followed.
The questions comments evaluations and analysis that occurs before during and after the presidents speech will clearly reveal information concerning political affiliations and probably critical appraisals of other individuals with whom the child(ren) has/have close family relationships (such as parents) the foundation said in a press release. This is perhaps one of the greatest invasions of personal privacy and injecting political affiliation into the public school system in the history of the United States.
The group said the speech may violate protections provided in the Pupil Rights Amendment.
It also violates 34 Code of Federal Regulations Section 98.4c 1 and 2 that defines psychological testing as:
(1) Psychiatric or psychological examination or test means a method of obtaining information including a group activity that is not directly related to academic instruction and that is designed to elicit information about attitudes habits traits opinions beliefs or feelings; (emphasis added) (2) Psychiatric or psychological treatment means an activity involving the planned systematic use of methods or techniques that are not directly related to academic instruction and that is designed to affect behavioral emotional or attitudinal characteristics of an individual or group. (emphasis added) Texas Justice Foundation warned that the group activities suggested by the Department of Education are not directly related to academic instruction and that are designed to elicit information about attitudes habits traits opinions beliefs or feelings. At this time of intense controversy over the presidents far-reaching plans to transform America it is incredible that he would consider using children to advance his political agenda Justice Foundation President Allan Parker said. It violates the constitutional right of parents to direct the upbringing and education of their children federal law and is perhaps the greatest intrusion of a president into the education process in the history of the United States. In the opinion of the Texas Justice Foundation lawyers it is both morally and legally wrong. Public relations tactic gone too far Neal McCluskey associate director of the Center for Educational Freedom objected to the Obama administration message to schoolchildren in a Cato Institute article titled Hey Obama leave those kids alone. Its one thing for a president to encourage all kids to work hard and stay in school thats a reasonable use of the bully pulpit McCluskey wrote. Its another thing
entirely however to have the U.S. Department of Education send detailed instructions to public schools nationwide on how to glorify the president and the presidency and push them to drive social change. Frighteningly this is what President Obama has done.
McCluskey objected to Department of Education-suggested classroom activities for pre-K-6 students encouraging children to make posters setting out community and country goals.
Perhaps even more frightening is the lesson schools are pushed to teach that it is important to listen to the president and other elected officials he wrote. Possibly most distressing of all though is guidance that appears explicitly designed to glorify both the presidency and President Obama himself …
He said the White House is trying to use its power over education to indoctrinate children something completely antithetical to a free society.
Missouri Lt. Gov. Peter Kinder condemned Obamas speech as a public relations tactic that has gone too far.
I believe that if parents choose to keep their children at home during this presentation they should be able to do so without any consequences being imposed upon their children Kinder said. And if local school districts across Missouri choose not to make this speech mandatory for students they should not face any penalties for the state or federal government.
Jim Greer chairman of the Florida Republican Party said in a statement that he believes Obamas speech may be a platform to spread his socialist ideology.
As the father of four children I am absolutely appalled that taxpayer dollars are being used to spread President Obamas socialist ideology. The idea that school children across our nation will be forced to watch the president justify his plans for government-run health care banks and automobile companies increasing taxes on those who create jobs and racking up more debt than any other president is not only infuriating but goes against beliefs of the majority of Americans while bypassing American parents through an invasive abuse of power.
He continued While I support educating our children to respect both the office of the American president and the value of community service I do not support using our children as tools to spread liberal propaganda. The address scheduled for Sept. 8 2009 does not allow for healthy debate on the presidents agenda but rather obligates the youngest children in our public school system to agree with our presidents initiatives or be ostracized by their teachers and classmates.
