By Randy Jones Chairman Texas Association of Business
Published: 09-30-08
This March as Texas and Ohio prepared for their historic presidential primaries The Wall Street Journal contrasted the economic outlooks of the two states. The editorial graphically illustrated the opposite policies they had pursued and the results of such — “growth” for Texas “pain” for Ohio.
Now that we’re less than two months from the general election a new comparison is in order — this time between Texas and California.
The importance of these two states is not just about electoral votes. Combined these states contribute 22 percent of America’s gross domestic product. Separately each would rank among the 10 largest economies in the world.
But while these states are America’s economic engines Texas’ purrs smoothly while California’s sputters on the verge of conking out. Of this year’s Fortune 500 companies 58 have their corporate headquarters in Texas versus 52 in California — the first time Texas has ever led this ranking.
And as with Ohio California’s current economic pain is self-inflicted.
People want to live where the jobs are plentiful and the salaries can provide a good standard of living for their families. Businesses are better able to provide those jobs where taxes regulations and government expenditures are low.
After all whether you’re an individual or a business who wants to risk their time and money if the potential rewards go to government rather than themselves?
A report released earlier this month by the Texas Public Policy Foundation spells out how these states’ dramatically different economic approaches have caused businesses to flock to Texas and flee California.
While Texas has a higher property tax burden and a 1 percent gross receipts tax that is particularly onerous to small businesses California has a higher state sales tax rate. The Golden State also assesses a corporate income tax and taxes on capital gains dividends and personal income that Texas does not.
Taken together Californians pay nearly 12 percent of their personal income in state taxes. In Texas that tax burden is less than 10 percent — and dropping.
Additionally California has a worse state legal climate higher workers’ compensation costs a higher state minimum wage and allows industries to force workers to join unions and pay union dues. All of these increase the operating costs to employers which reduces their ability to compete against rivals in other states and countries.
Government spending also matters to businesses. Higher government spending not only correlates to a higher tax burden but a greater likelihood that those tax dollars will be spent on bureaucracies that meddle in a business’ day-to-day activities.
Here is where the difference is most pronounced. California’s per-capita government spending is 30 percent higher compared to Texas and that gap continues to widen.
How much do these factors matter?
In the past year Texas has added almost 250000 new jobs — more than half of the national total. California has shed 200000 jobs just in the past four months and boasts one of the highest unemployment rates in the country.
As employers move so do workers. Four of America’s 10 fastest-growing metropolitan areas are in Texas. Nearly half a million residents of other states have moved to Texas since 2000 while almost 1 million Californians have fled the Golden State.
And as both employers and workers move so do their tax dollars. In January the Texas Legislature will return to a cash balance in the $10 billion to $15 billion range. Today California grapples with closing a $15 million to $17 billion budget deficit for next year as well as structural deficits well into the foreseeable future.
The fortunes of Texas and California aren’t the product of sheer luck. These states are where they are today because of the policy decisions they have made over many years. Texas is better positioned for the future because of its leadership’s unrelenting commitment to fiscal discipline and regulatory certainty.
Gov. Perry and Texas legislators have understood that the overwhelming majority of people can take better care of themselves with a job and its opportunity than government can take care of them with a program and its bureaucracy.
The dire headlines coming out of California show what will happen if they forget that lesson.
Randy Jones is chairman of the board of the Texas Association of Business.
