Blame Congress not presidents Bush or Obama for our perilous fiscal situation.
By Steve Moore
Texas Insider Report: WASHINGTON D.C. During a recent press conference President Obama blamed George W. Bush for the nations fiscal condition. When I walked in he declared wrapped in a nice bow was a $1.3 trillion deficit sitting right there on my doorstep. Earlier this year he asserted that we came in with $8 trillion worth of debt over the next decade.
Neither statement is correct according to the Congressional Budget Office (CBO).
True enough the outgoing Bush administration bequeathed big deficits to Mr. Obama. The expected 2009 deficit was $1.19 trillion not $1.3 trillion howeverand the actual deficit for 2009 came in at $1.41 trillion meaning that the new president added some $220 billion to the total.
In some ways Herbert Hoover got a bad rap says David Stockman in an interview with WSJs Alan Murray. The Former Reagan Administration budget director lays out a plan for economic recovery by cutting spending raising taxes and allowing for years of austerity.
.Far more significant however was the presidents misstatement that Mr. Bush and the Republicans left the country with $8 trillion of debt over the next 10 years. The CBOs projected 10-year deficit when Mr. Obama took office was actually $4.09 trillion. Now after 20 months of his presidency the expected deficit has almost doubled to $7.68 trillion.
A strong case can be made that the people most responsible for the gigantic deficits we face today are neither George W. Bush nor Barack Obama. The
real culprits are Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid.
Congress controls the purse strings. When Mrs. Pelosi and Mr. Reid rose to their present jobs in January 2007 the deficit was $161 billion. It had been on a downward trajectory from $413 billion in 2004. Three years later the Pelosi-Reid Congress had added $1.2 trillion to the deficit.
Of course Mr. Bush sponsored or signed into law many of these deficit-raising bills such as the bank bailouts and effective tax rebates of 2008. But the Democratic Congress passed them.
Long forgotten is the promise Mrs. Pelosi made on the day she became speaker: Our new America will provide unlimited opportunity for future generations not burden them with mountains of debt. I think future generations would like a do-over.
Today Mr. Obama and Democrats in Congress love to talk about how Mr. Bush turned a $200 billion Clinton surplus into a $1 trillion deficit. Indeed he did though they ignore the 9/11 terrorist attacks that happened less than a year after Mr. Bush became president. Those attacks were fiscal game-changers jolting the economy to a temporary standstill and requiring unplanned spending for homeland security and antiterrorism efforts.
For the sake of comparison lets look at the Pelosi-Reid fiscal record over 10 years. In January 2007 the CBO projected a $379 billion surplus over the next decade. Now after four years under Mrs. Pelosi and Mr. Reid and two years of Mr. Obama in the White House the 2007-2016 projection is a deficit of $7.16 trillion.
This deterioration of the nations fiscal situation is arguably the worst in United States history and it was brought to us courtesy of a congressional leadership that pledged pay as you go budgeting to bring the budget into balance.
It is no wonder that Americans are not eager to retain the services of these two spendthrifts as leaders of Congress.
Mr. Moore is senior economics writer for The Wall Street Journal editorial page.
