Parties Nearly Tied for Congress in 2010 Bears Watching
by Lydia Saad Gallop
PRINCETON NJ -- Roughly a year before the 2010 midterm elections Gallup finds the Republican and Democratic Parties nearly tied in the congressional ballot preferences of registered voters. Forty-six percent of registered voters say they would vote for the Democrat and 44 say the Republican when asked which partys candidate they would support for Congress if the election were held today.
The Democratic Party
held a slightly wider six percentage-point lead on this important indicator of party strength in July 50 to 44. However both 2009 results show a more competitive political environment than Gallup has generally seen since before the Democrats regained control of the U.S. House of Representatives in the 2006 midterm elections. Closer to elections Gallup bases its results on likely voters. Doing so typically improves the Republicans positioning by several points; thus when Democrats lead slightly among registered voters it is possible for Republicans to be ahead among likely voters.
The Republican Partys relatively strong position on the generic ballot in the latest poll conducted Oct. 1-4 stems from the support of political independents who now favor Republican over Democratic candidates by 45 to 36.As Gallups generic ballot trend shows the Democrats held a sizable lead among registered voters from about March 2006 through most of 2008. The Republicans nearly tied the Democrats immediately following the Republican National Convention in September 2008 but that proved short-lived. The gap widened to 7 points by mid-October and
to 15 points immediately prior to the 2008 elections -- not only securing the Democrats victory but enabling them to greatly expand their majority position.
The closeness of the two parties in voter preferences today is similar to that found in most Gallup readings from 1994 through 2005 (spanning the period when Republicans won control of the U.S. House and subsequently maintained it for more than a decade).
The Republican Partys relatively strong position on the generic ballot in the latest poll conducted Oct. 1-4 stems from the support of political independents who now favor Republican over Democratic candidates by 45 to 36. In July independents were evenly divided in their party voting preferences whereas last fall they showed a clear preference for the Democrats.
Across these surveys at least 90 each of Republicans and of Democrats have said they plan to vote for their own partys candidate. Today that figure is 93 for the Democrats and 92 for the Republicans.
Congressional Approval Bears Watching
Gallups latest congressional job approval rating provides an additional sign that the 2010 elections could be challenging for Democratic candidates:
21 of Americans approve and 72 disapprove. Approval of Congress is now low across all three partisan groups but is exceptionally weak among Republicans (9) and independents (16).
By comparison with presidential elections midterm elections are low-turnout affairs that put much more focus on the races for Congress. Congress has seen approval ratings below 30 in a midterm year most recently in 2006 (with 26 approving in October and in early November). In that years elections the Republicans lost majority control of Congress after 12 years in power. Previously Gallup measured sub-30 approval in 1994 (23 approved in October) when the Democrats lost majority control after 40 years in power. Prior to that in 1990 26 of Americans approved of the job Congress was doing in early November yet the Democrats held their majority in that election.
For most of 2009 prior to Gallups Oct. 1-4 survey congressional approval had been in the 30s. Thus the latest 21 reading -- still more than a year away from the election -- merely represents a preliminary indication of possible trouble for the incumbent party. The 2010 readings will be much more instructive in forecasting the national two-party vote for Congress which can in turn be used to estimate the division of seats.
Bottom Line
For the second time this year Gallup polling shows the Republicans within single digits of the Democrats in the congressional voting preferences of registered voters. Thats a distinct shift away from the larger Democratic leads seen since the Democrats won back control of Congress in 2006 and a sign that if the 2010 elections were held today Republicans would likely outperform Democrats given usual turnout patterns.
The challenge for congressional Democrats is underscored by todays low approval of Congress. While it is far too early to say whether these indicators spell real trouble for the Democrats in 2010 they could provide some encouragement to the Republicans.
Survey Methods
Results are based on telephone interviews with 1013 national adults aged 18 and older conducted Oct. 1-4 2009. For results based on the total sample of national adults one can say with 95 confidence that the maximum margin of sampling error is ±4 percentage points.
For results based on the sample of 906 registered voters the maximum margin of sampling error is ±4 percentage points.
Interviews are conducted with respondents on land-line telephones (for respondents with a land-line telephone) and cellular phones (for respondents who are cell-phone only).
In addition to sampling error question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.
For further poll details & Gallop information
please click here.
