By Sheriff David Clarke (Ret.)
By The timing of the Alabama state legislatures abortion bill that makes it the most restrictive in the nation is perfect. It is perfect because as we enter a national election in 2020 it will be a front and center issue before the electoratea better platform than before the Supreme Court. I dont want the fate of an unborn child to be a judicial decision instead of a legislative one. Since the Supreme Court has determined that an unborn child has no constitutional protection to life until the third trimester this decision should be returned to the states to decide under the Tenth Amendment.
Here are a few observations.
It is interesting that Governor Kay Ivey and the legislature indicated that they already know that this will end up in the federal courts while Virginia and New York are considering aborting a child up to delivery and have no such reservations about those laws ending up in federal court.
The Alabama law allows for an abortion only if it is necessary to save the life of the woman. The current U.S. Supreme Court standard under Roe v. Wade holds in part that states may prohibit abortion after fetal viability so long as there are exceptions for the life and health (both physical and mental) of the woman.
Here is the elephant in the room that gets ignored in abortion discussions. The elephant is that abortion and race merits a discussion. We usually hear from white advocates for murdering babies but they are never asked about its disparate impact on people of color as they like to call us. According to Right to Life of Michigan statistics More than crime. More than accidents. More than cancer heart disease and AIDS. Abortion has taken more Black American lives than every other cause of death combined since 1973. In the United States the abortion rate for Black women is almost four times that of White women. In 2014 36 of all abortions were performed on black women. On average 900 Black babies are aborted every day in the United States. This tragedy continues to impact the population levels of African Americans in the United States." It goes on to say that since the 1973 landmark decision 19 million black babies have been aborted. Let that statistic sink in for a moment. For those who think that my comparison of black baby abortion with the holocaust is over the top; the definition of holocaust is the mass slaughter and reckless destruction of life.
Another interesting observation is how Republican politicians handle an interview on the Alabama abortion law. They still stammer stumble and talk all around the issue trying to get to a non-answer. It is embarrassing. House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy said that he believes the Alabama law goes too far because it doesnt allow abortion in the case of rape and incest. Why did he allow himself to be dragged down that rabbit hole? Rape and incest account for 1.5 of abortions. That means 98.5 of abortions do not involve rape or incest so what is he talking about? That excuse allowed him an escape. McCarthy said that he believes that the most precious gift God gives is the gift of life. Really Kevin? The Alabama law proves how precious life is. Your dribble does not.
McCarthy like many GOP politicians would rather not have to talk about it and that is why the timing of the Alabama law is perfect. Dont you hate politicians who have no stable clear core political beliefs things they wont waffle on no matter what even if it means election defeat? They talk the talk on abortion but wont walk the full walk. They take positions publicly yet everything has a qualifying but". They are pro-life but... They support the Second Amendment but... They support religious freedom but... We need to find out what GOP politicians are genuinely pro-life and which ones use it to virtue signal in front of GOP audiences to get a good score from pro-life organizations they can flaunt at election time.
Therefore what is it that makes McCarthy think that the Alabama law goes too far if he believes that life is Gods most precious gift to us? Keep in mind that McCarthy is a House member representing California. Perhaps that influences his answer when talking about abortion. In the 2018 midterm elections Democrats won 8 congressional House seats that had been held by Republicans for several decades in the GOP stronghold of Orange County California. Only 7 GOP members are left out of 53. They no doubt have McCarthy in their crosshairs.
Why cant Republican politicians handle this question with authority and without ambiguity? I think they are afraid of losing female voters even though polling shows opinions are shifting back toward the protection of the unborn. That was an ambush question and as could be predicted the liberal media used a Republican answer in headlines to slam Alabamas law as extreme. No such headline appeared containing a high profile Democrat supporting New York and Virginias savage law allowing the killing of viable children in the third trimester.
The American people have long demonstrated a moral and constitutional obligation to protect vulnerable and defenseless persons. A growing number of states are stretching the limits on the killing of babies through the third trimester and including post delivery with few legal challenges. The Alabama law isnt extreme. It protects the life of the unborn. Killing viable babies in the third trimester is extreme. Its time to push back. There is no time like the present.
