Answering 20 Questions Liberals Wanted to Ask a Conservative

By John Hawkins Since Donald Trump became president liberals have been…lets just say... EXTREMELY upset. On the other hand even as someone who was not a fan of Trump I have been very happy with his performance. In fact so far I dont think anything Trump has done is radical. Its more of a re-balancing towards sanity and common sense. So with that disconnect between how conservatives and liberals see things in mind I thought it would be a good idea to answer questions liberals have for conservatives. So I asked on Twitter. John Hawkins @johnhawkinsrwn: Im doing a Townhall column where Ill honestly w/out sarcasm answer liberal questions to conservatives. Any libs want to ask questions?" A few people including Peter Daou Dave Weigel and Robert Gibson were kind enough to retweet me and I received an enormous number of questions. Although I tend to doubt that liberals will like most of the answers I give I will at least be polite in my responses and maybe it will do some good. Enjoy! 1) JC ?@JCrock_ Do Rs honestly believe voter fraud is a real issue and not just a blatant excuse to suppress min vote. Please provide proof. I dont believe Trump is right when he claims he would have won the popular vote if not for illegal aliens voting. However I do believe voter fraud is an issue. As to evidence whether you like him or not I think James OKeefe has done a phenomenal job of pointing out vulnerabilities in our system that could be used for fraud. Furthermore the Heritage Foundation has put out a pretty extensive list of voter fraud cases.  Then theres the study from Jesse Richman from Old Dominion University in Virginia that claims as many as 800000 illegal aliens voted. Is he right? I dont know but it does seem like something we should take seriously enough to investigate. 2) Michele Passarelli ?@ShellyPass Why are conservatives anti-progress? Conservatives love progress. Its just that what we consider progress and you consider progress are very different. For example building a wall? That would be progress. Reducing the number of people on welfare? Progress. Revamping our immigration system in order to improve the quality of immigrants were getting? Progress. Cutting into the deficit reducing regulations lowering taxes? To conservatives those are steps forward that help the country progress towards a brighter future. 3) Christopher Wensley?@mipolitico If youre a Christian how do you reconcile Good Samaritan/Sermon of the Mount with Trump denying Arab children safe passage? I am a Christian and I dont think Trump has gone far enough with refugees. Currently the number hes going to allow overall is roughly in line with historical standards. Given that we have a huge deficit and bringing in refugees equates to bringing in people who will be on public assistance long-term I dont think thats a good idea. Moreover getting back to the reality of the situation... Whats going on in Syria today is essentially the same thing that happened in Rwanda Bosnia Cambodia and smaller locales around the world. By the time Syria finally fades from the news well be hearing the same stories from some other country. As a Christian do I want to see us help these countries? Sure. Should we be sending them food clothing and other basic necessities? Privately definitely. Publicly Im not as sure but I wont complain about us helping someone in need and maybe in the most extreme of circumstances even helping out with our military. However its not our job to bring in the billions of people on the planet who are desperately poor in a war torn area or just have a horrible life. In fact if we did do that all wed accomplish would be to turn ourselves into another one of those horrible countries. Put another way our moral obligation to do good and help people does not extend to making them American citizens and handing them a welfare check. 4) mrcz0323 ?@mrcz032308  Why do so many people say Trump isnt racist? Or say they voted for him despite that and feel ok with it? Of all the flaws that Trump may have I thought it was particularly odd that this was the one that most liberals seem to have wholeheartedly embraced. I have criticized Trump for what I thought at the time was a very lackluster attempt to distance himself from some of the crazier Alt-Right types who were worshipping him but since then he has denounced them in strong terms. So with that said I dont even know anything off the top of my head that hes said or done that would make me think hes racist. Hes certainly expressed doubts about Muslims but theyre not a race. Wanting to put an end to illegal immigration certainly isnt racist. If anything hes reached out to black Americans more than previous GOP nominees. Respectfully I think people tend to see what they expect to see in the political opposition. Whoever the next Democratic nominee is Republicans will be worried about them taking our guns raising taxes and expanding government and liberals will worry that whoever comes after Trump is racist hates the poor and wants to kill Social Security. Thats just a feature of American politics. 5) blue in a red state ?@thewaybyelle Doesnt the president alarm you? What do you think about mass resignations & attempts to silence agencies? Conservatives have a different view of these bureaucracies. I LOVE the mass resignations and as to silencing agencies theyre not independent of the president. He should have the right to staff them with people who share his views dramatically reduce their numbers and make sure theyre not undermining his agenda. If anything other Republican presidents have been far too reluctant to make major changes in these agencies and its good to see Trump making some changes. 6) Noah Wasserman?@nmwass How do conservatives square a pro-life abortion policy with persistent attacks against the welfare state? To start with I think its morally wrong to kill a child and I cant in good conscience ever be okay with that except under the direst of circumstances (danger to the mothers life and more reluctantly rape and incest). So then the question becomes if I think that way how do I not support the state taking care of a mother who cant afford her child? Not every conservative would say this but I do believe welfare food stamps etc should exist. That being said public assistance should be a short-term measure given to people in dire straits. I think if it actually fit that definition youd seldom ever hear conservatives talk about it. However conservatives believe the system is being exploited by people who want to turn what should be a temporary measure into something long-term. Not only is that bad for taxpayers whose charity is being abused its bad for the people who stay on public assistance over long periods of time. Ive actually had conservatives ask me if I think its okay for them to take public assistance. Ive always told them I thought it was fine as long as it was a temporary measure and they felt embarrassed by having to do it. At least if they think that way it means their heads are in the right place about taking money that someone else worked to earn. 7) Privately Worrying ?@derivativeburke If conservatives believed in the marketplace of ideas and observed voter fraud is low wouldnt they want everyone to vote? A lot of conservatives look at it differently. Should we want people who are getting government assistance to vote? Should we want people whove committed felonies to vote? Should we want people who dont know which party Joe Biden belongs to voting? Should we want people to vote who pick the candidate they support based on which one is taller? If anything the country would probably be better off if we had a smaller group of voters who were more informed and more invested in the country voting. So its a different way of looking at things. 8) Sandycpf ?@Framerchick  Why are they so against an investigation into Russian ties with Donald Trump? I dont think conservatives are against an investigation into Russia per se. Donald Trump is probably against it because hes trying to thaw relations with Russia and doesnt back an investigation that may be used as a tool to undermine his legitimacy. In any case there are going to be investigations. There should be. If Russia was attempting to interfere in our elections thats not okay and there should be consequences for that. All that being said after our intelligence agencies so badly botched the WMDs in Iraq issue (Slam Dunk") I think people have a right to be a little skeptical until we get more information. 9) Political Troll ?@polititrolls What is up with the obsession some conservatives have with cuckoldry? Thats a weird cultural thing that has become popular with the Alt-Right. If you see someone calling someone else a cuck" theres about a 90 chance that youll find something on their timeline praising Hitler or freaking out about Jews. Online it may seem like a lot of people but they seem to be a small group of people in the real world. 10) Bae Talese ?@elongreen  Why dont conservatives seem to give a damn about climate change? Pete Sikora ?@PeteSikora1 Why are conservatives so into climate denial when their future is also at stake? Put simply were dubious of the evidence that says its occurring and believe much of it is driven by government grants as opposed to real science. Moreover many of the plans to fix it seem incredibly expensive inconvenient or unworkable. Personally I think we should certainly keep investigating global warming but it would take much stronger scientific evidence to convince me that it was a problem we need to make major changes to address. 11) dorkasaurus_rex?@dorkasaurus_rex Would love to. What is the conservative view of Trumps infrastructure plan? Good bad socialism? Personally I think Keynesian economic stimulus has proven to be ineffective time and time again and I dont think itll magically work just because Trump happens to be president. Im guessing a large number of conservatives feel that way. Unfortunately stimulus plans do tend to be politically popular and both parties exert a lot of pressure on members of Congress to back major initiatives of the president. So it may pass maybe even with major Democratic help since they tend to be fans of stimulus spending but it probably wont accomplish much other than adding to the debt at the end of the day. 12) requiem ?@awrichner Where is the line for you? what action could Trump take that would ensure youd fight against him and his supporters? G$ Climate Sci ?@ClimEducator_BG Where is your red line? What wont you sign off on? Patrick Fessenbecker ?@pfessenbecker Ill bite. What would have to happen to make meaningful conservative opposition to Trump occur? The final straw that convinced me that I needed to write in Ted Cruz instead of voting for Trump was his public statement saying that we should kill the families of terrorists followed up by him promising that no soldier was going to be allowed to disobey his direct order to do that. In retrospect that was probably just Trump saying something that he thought made him sound tough followed up with him lashing out in generalized annoyance after he was attacked. So that would be a bridge too far for me. Trump is just as bound by the Constitution as any other president and IF he does something that I believe goes outside of that I think many of us will oppose that policy. 13) Ignatz   ?? ?? ?@iggy_uffda  Do you still believe Trumps business conflicts wont be a problem after seeing the countries included/excluded in the ban? So two separate issues. First of all I know a lot of people have noted that Trump has done no business with the nations that are facing extreme vetting. On the other hand as my friend Ed Morrissey has noted the group of nations he picked make perfect sense Again: 6 of the 7 are failed or marginal states where Islamist terror networks hold ground. Other is Iran largest state sponsor of terror." As to Trumps business conflicts I do think theyre a problem. After all even if hes having his kids run his businesses the companies still have his name on them. Would it be easy to see big spenders pumping money into his business ventures in hopes of potentially gaining favor with Trump? Absolutely. On the other hand even as someone who didnt support Trump I have to admit that asking Trump to sell his entire business empire especially when a great deal of the value is tied to his name doesnt necessarily seem reasonable. Additionally Trump has apparently done all of what he promised to do on the campaign trail which was let his kids take over. Its not a perfect solution but I dont know that there is one. 14) JC ?@JCrock_ Free press is fundamental to democracy. So why do Rs only trust media that flatters current admin much like state run media? A free press is fundamental to our republic. Unfortunately we live in a world where almost every outlet has chosen sides. They hire people who agree with them ideologically and they choose what stories they run or bury based on which side it impacts. Some of them have different approaches but at the end of the day Right Wing News =s Breitbart =s Townhall and CNN =s the Washington Post =s the Huffington Post. When conservatives didnt feel like they were getting fair treatment from liberal outfits they moved on to conservative ones while liberals were content to get their news from people who largely agreed with them. So I guess you could say its more like there are TWO state run Medias out there servicing different halves of the population. 15) Matt Needham ?@MattNeedham91 Why should we allow Bannon to wield power & influence? There were a lot of questions about Steve Bannon so it seems appropriate that I discuss him even though its hard to give you a good answer. The reason I say that is that there are a couple of people that I like and respect (Ben Shapiro & Dana Loesch) who believe with some justification as far as I can tell that hes not a great guy. On the other hand I also have friends at Breitbart whove worked with him who say hes a terrific person. So on a personal level its hard for me to know what to think. On the other hand I do know Bannon was extremely successful at Breitbartand apparently he was an integral part of the team that got Trump elected when almost everyone except true believers thought he was going down in a heap. So for now Im giving him the benefit of the doubt. PS: I think his notorious statement about making Breitbart the platform of the Alt-Right" was probably a poorly thought out bit of pandering. In the real world Breitbart is not a racist publication or an Alt-Right website" in any meaningful sense. So I dont know whats in Steve Bannons heart but I havent seen any evidence that convinces me that hes a racist much less a white nationalist." 16) Bill Pieper ?@WilliamPieper How can a conservative square the funding request for the wall with past demands that spending be offset elsewhere? The majority of the federal governments spending today is on things it shouldnt be doing anyway. On the other hand the first duties of the government should be protecting us from foreign invaders securing our border and establishing order. Building a fence is an important part of that. Additionally if Congress cooperates it is actually possible to make Mexico pay for the wall via taxing remittances and holding back aid. Many people think thats just an applause line but it doesnt have to be. Last but not least the centerpiece of Trumps agenda was promising to build a wall. That produces an enormous amount of pressure on Republicans to support it regardless of how its paid for. 17) Pete Sikora ?@PeteSikora1 Also does it bother you that tiny #s of richest people have the same wealth as bottom half of entire world pop? No because I dont think income inequality is a particularly meaningful barometer of fairness or economic health. How does Bill Gates or Warren Buffet having nearly infinite money make my life or yours worse? It doesnt. If anything the amount of taxes theyre paying and jobs theyre creating are good for the country as a whole. Would we be better off if they didnt exist or were taxed into oblivion so the money could be redistributed? I dont think so. Were better off having them out there doing what theyre doing and thus inspiring other people to try to match their level of success. I grew up hearing stories from a father who lived through the Depression. You know soda pop and peanut butter was a luxury couldnt afford haircuts etc. Without question things have improved across the board for Americans today. Quite a lot actually Between 1969 and 2007 incomes for Americans in the bottom fifth of the income distribution rose by 46 compared with a 63 increase for Americans in the middle fifth. 18) Delll ?@DelDink1  Why do conservatives assume that Black peoples views on society are a result of brainwashing by the left rather than by our own experience? I think because a lot of what we hear said doesnt square with our experiences. I grew up in the Deep South saw almost no racism publicly and heard very little privately. When I did hear it it mostly came from really old guys who came of age in a different era. Racists definitely exist. Let me repeat that; racists definitely exist. Are they a common thing or are they largely pathetic Cletuses along with a few pseudo-intellectuals and some doddering old guys who cant get their heads out of the fifties? For the most part I think its the latter. Additionally almost every conservative alive now has experience with being called a racist for no good reason. When you dont bear any ill will towards any race and youre constantly being accused of it on the flimsiest of grounds you start to believe theres some going on other than people just recognizing reality. 19) John Hare ?@johnahare Is there any point at which the electoral college/popular vote split would become a concern? Whichever way you go there are issues. The Electoral College was intended to force candidates to spend time in small states and it does this very well. I also believe its probably a better system overall than going the popular vote route. For one thing going by the popular vote would cause the candidates to spend most of their time in states like California Texas New York and Florida. Additionally can you imagine the nightmare that would have ensued in the 2000 election between Gore and Bush if that election were decided by the national popular vote? You could have had lawsuits in every state and it may have taken months to hash it all out. Additionally keep in mind that the popular vote has only diverged from the Electoral College 4 times in history. Moreover many liberals may assume that Gore and Clinton would have been elected if the popular vote were the deciding factor but thats not necessarily true. Keep in mind that the type of campaign run by the Republican in those elections would have been entirely different if the popular vote were the deciding factor. Last but not least if and when the Democrats take Texas in a presidential election you will immediately see both sides flip on whether the popular vote should be the deciding factor. 20) Chris ?@howlingchris  Why are you more comfortable with banning foreigners than banning assault weapons? Two reasons. First we have a Second Amendment that guarantees us the right to own firearms. Getting beyond that to assault weapons in particular they have a bad rap but the numbers dont match the hype. You dont have to believe me because even the New York Times admits that its true. The law that barred the sale of assault weapons from 1994 to 2004 made little difference. It turns out that big scary military rifles dont kill the vast majority of the 11000 Americans murdered with guns each year. Little handguns do. In 2012 only 322 people were murdered with any kind of rifle F.B.I. data shows. As to foreigners like many conservatives I believe that whether we allow someone to come into the United States is entirely dependent on whether it benefits us or not. So tourists diplomats? Sure. Immigrants who come to the United States embrace our country and add to the tax base? Yes. Immigrants who come here and take advantage of our welfare system? No. Illegal immigrants? No. People who are probably fine on the whole but are much more likely than average to have a few terrorists in their ranks? At a minimum they need more vetting. Again the whole point of allowing someone to come to this country should be to benefit the people who already live here.