Marches demonstrate how the Left has become better at protesting than winning elections.
By Steven Malanga
Texas Insider Report: WASHINGTON D.C. The abundance of recent marches and protests in cities around the country seems to have been a cathartic moment for the Left. Many in
the media reveled in the explosion of energy" the thundering roar" and
the stinging rebuke" to President Donald Trump represented by this supposedly spontaneous resistance" movement. Yet come Monday

morning Trump was still president and Republicans still held both houses of Congress.
And while some Democratic governors and mayors pledge to resist Trump Republicans have enjoyed a remarkable string of victories at the state and local levels during the last eight years. The GOP holds 33 state legislatures (to just 16 for Democrats) and 33 governorships. If marches and protests demonstrate anything its that the Left has become better at organizing protests than winning elections.
Its not accidental
The new Democratic Party the one increasingly governed by identity politics and driven by special interests has become so intoxicated by the nostrums of
Saul Alinsky and his Rules for Radicals" that it has forgotten how to operate in a democracy where elections count more than revolutionary theater.
Perhaps this is the inevitable result of elevating a charismatic former community organizer to the presidency. President Obama was a gifted campaign strategist and an appealing personality but he convinced his party that the Alinsky model was a viable permanent approach to governing. True it often

worked for him but success led him to use it as a crutch even after he assumed the worlds most powerful office.
Were going to speak truth to power" presidential advisor Valerie Jarrett once said when asked about media bias against Obamas policies. As political scientist Pete Peterson pointed out however Youre the White House. You are the power."
Obama inspired a generation of like-minded Democrats to follow him into the protest-as-politics movement. Bill de Blasio has been an elected official in New York City for 15 years now having served on the city council and as public advocate and now as mayor. Yet he attends protests as if he were a powerless outsider and occasionally invites arrest"
according to the New York Times.
In a city dominated by left-leaning Democrats getting arrested on purpose is good politics. More recently de Blasio participated in protests in front of Trump Tower
even as chaos reigned for many of the local businesses nearby.
The posturing is wearing thin even among political allies
In a telling piece published last week in the
Washington Post Asra Nomani a journalist and former instructor at Brandeis and Yale described why she a liberal feminist refused to participate in Saturdays

marches.
The march really isnt a womens march. Its a march for women who are anti-Trump" she wrote detailing the many Democratic-backed groups and former Hillary Clinton donors who were funding the protests.
Nomani a Muslim woman and the author of The Islamic Bill of Rights for Women in Mosques" noted that the march had made white women feel unwelcome and obfuscated the issues of Islamic extremism."
The inconsistencies of protesters goes well beyond Nomanis observations. More than one critic wondered where the hundreds of thousands of protestors were when Bill Clintons personal behavior toward women was exposed as abusive and exploitative. Clinton may have been an SOB but he was apparently the Lefts SOB.
That makes the outrage over Trump sound hollow.
Of Alinskys 13 rules" the one that has undermined the credibility of Democrats the most is their single-minded pursuit of Number Five: Ridicule is mans most potent weapon." Its difficult to remember a Republican president or candidate whom Democrats havent tried to paint as either a warmonger or an

imbecile.
Comedian
Bill Maher said it best when he admitted that the derision heaped on George W. Bush John McCain and Mitt Romney finally backfired in this election.
They were honorable men who we disagreed with and we should have kept it that way" Maher said.
So we cried wolf and that was wrong."
His point? Unlike the others Trump really is a menace. His admission had little effect. A large portion of the electorate had already stopped listening.
From Occupy Wall Street to Black Lives Matters to the Womens March the Left launched a blizzard of noteworthy protest movements during the last eight years. At the same time Democrats suffered
unprecedented electoral carnage.
The party is now in its weakest position nationally since the 1920s leaving Republicans whether in Congress or in state capitals to act as the chief restraining influence on a president whose agenda and governing temperament still raise doubts among reasonable people.

Maybe the Democrats are not so much beneficiaries of Alinskys wisdom as victims of it.
Steven Malanga is the senior editor of City Journal a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute and the author of Shakedown: The Continuing Conspiracy Against the American Taxpayer.